Schmackary’s is a specialty cookie shop in Hell’s Kitchen. There’s an extensive menu of cookies here, many seasonal, and they don’t have all the cookies all of the time. On my trip, I got sea salt chocolate chip, red velvet cookie with walnut buttercream frosting, chocolate duet, pumpkin spice and candied yam.
I first had Schmackary’s at the Ninth Avenue Festival when they gave out a free sample of the chocolate diablo cookie, and it was really good. I thought the sea salt chocolate chip was delicious, a good balance between chewy and crispy.
All the cookies were good, but there was a thick, floury kind of aftertaste in the pumpkin and yam cookies. I definitely preferred the former three cookies to the latter two. I’d like to try the sweet corn cookie (gluten-free) made with corn flour and sweet corn.