Things are great at Keens Steakhouse. It won a James Beard “America’s Classics” award this year, and since then, business has really been booming. Not that the 128-year-old steakhouse needed an award–it’s obviously doing something right. And that’s steak…atmosphere…service…and dessert.
Speaking of atmosphere, the first thing(s) you notice when you step down the steps, besides the dark wood, is/are the thousands of pipes, yes, pipes, hanging all over the ceiling.
The history is that travelers would check their pipe in at their favorite inn because the pipes were too fragile to be carried. They are hard clay churchwarden pipes, and famous names like Babe Ruth, Teddy Roosevelt and Albert Einstein had pipes at Keens. Right by the door, there’s a case, including an autographed pipe from Michael Jackson and other present-day celebrities.
I didn’t know about this history before eating at Keens, so it was an interesting, fun history to learn.
My dinner at Keens was a belated birthday dinner with a friend. I was instantly pleased that along with a bread basket and butter, we got veggies and spinach dip for a somewhat clean-eating snack. (Hey, we needed some celery before this meal.)
For appetizers, we got littleneck clams on the half shell.
Tomatoes and onion salad with blue stilton cheese. I like that there was just a sprinkling of cheese on the tomatoes and onion. Just the right amount of flavor.
Thick-cut smoked bacon. My friend ordered this. I’m not a bacon fan, but I decided to take a taste. Oh wow, this was so smoky and flavorful. This is definitely not your average bacon of bacon and eggs….
Keens is known for its mutton chop, but I wanted steak. I know I’m not a big steak eater, but lately, I’ve been enjoying it. So I got the steamed Maine lobster and filet mignon. The lobster was perfect and delicious. The filet mignon was cooked to my liking. It was very good–not as tender as the one I recently had at the Old Homestead, but still excellent.
My friend got the prime rib of beef, king’s cut.
For sides, we got mashed Yukon gold potatoes and creamed spinach. I like mashed potatoes without garlic, so I was very happy with these. I also liked the creamed spinach best of all I’ve had recently.
We were pretty full after this meal, but our waiter talked us into a dessert. Yes, the butterscotch sundae, with housemade butterscotch sauce made with real scotch. They brought it with a birthday candle for me.
OK, I usually find steakhouse desserts boring, like the standard cheesecake, chocolate cake, key lime pie…but this sundae takes the cake…er, ice cream.
This butterscotch sauce was sooooo good, we both want to come back and get our own. I wanted to get a close-up so you could see it better.
Yes, there is a reason Keens has been in business for more than a century, and that is because it serves classic food that is delicious.